The Obamas private beach in Martha’s Vineyard could soon be opened to the public if a millionaire developer gets his way in a long-running legal battle.
Boston real estate mogul Richard Friedman has been fighting his neighbors in the wealthy enclave for years over access to a two-mile stretch of barrier beach, Oyster Pond.
He bought a 20-acree property in 1983, believing the purchase gave him ownership of the barrier beach. But his wealthy neighbors disagreed, saying they owned the beach.
A lengthy legal saga ensued that was ultimately brought to an end by natural erosion and shifts in the beach’s sands.
As the court battle went on for decades, Friedman decided that, since the private beaches had by this point moved north to rest between two bodies of water considered ‘public’ under Massachusetts law – Oyster Pond and Jobs Neck Pond – no private entity should be able to lay claim to them.
Now Democratic governor Maura Healy is pushing to open the beach stretch to the public, adding a measure to a $3 billion environmental bond bill that would define a barrier beach which moves – whether by erosion or rising sea levels – on to public land as public property.
The bill declares that a beach that moves into the ‘former bottom of the great pond shall be and remain in Commonwealth ownership in perpetuity.’
Hundreds of homeowners would be affected if the measure passes, including Barack and Michelle Obama, whose 28-acre estate includes a barrier beach that would become open to the public.
As the Boston Globe points out, Friedman is a Healy donor and is even scheduled to host a fundraiser for her this weekend.
Critics of the bill have accused her of doing a donor’s bidding but she insists the planned law will open more of her state’s most stunning beaches to regular people who aren’t super-rich.
The Democrat has denied being swayed by her wealthy donor. Her spokesperson said in a statement: ‘As someone who grew up on the Seacoast, Governor Healey has always felt strongly about increasing public access to beaches and great ponds.’
The Obamas purchased the sprawling vacation home on Martha’s Vineyard for $11.75 million in 2020.
The battle between millionaire families has been raging since a century ago, when two wealthy clans – the Nortons and the Flynns – with oceanside mansions carved out the beach overlooking Oyster Pond, claiming land rights to large slices of the shoreline.
The Norton land is now owned by three trusts – with Friedman being the principal owner, and the Flynn land is owned by six trusts.
Last September, a court ruled against Richard and in favor of the neighbors who say they own the beach.
Representatives for the Flynn trusts have been fighting Friedman’s efforts for decades, and experts told the Boston Globe that the law would likely invite lawsuits from the affected homeowners of properties with private beaches.
Eric Peters, one of the attorneys for the Flynn trusts, said ‘There is no public interest promoted’ by this bill…Rather, this legislation promotes the of a real estate developer.’
Friedman’s lawyers meanwhile have claimed 28 beaches that are now considered private would be open to the public if the law is changed.
Friedman is the developer behind the famed Charles Hotel in Cambridge and the Liberty Hotel in Boston.